What is The Best Dust Extractor?
Not all dust extractors and vacuums do that, though. To help you find one that does, I’ve picked the five best dust cleanup tools around, and I’ve reviewed each of them based on their abilities to do the three things you should be judging them on.
1. Makita XCV11Z — Amazon’s Choice
- Powerful BL Brushless motor delivers 57 cfm and 27...
- Filter cleaning system is designed to maintain...
The Makita is a portable option with a lot of power behind it. It’s not flawless, but its two minor flaws are heavily outweighed by the number of advantages it provides, and that’s why it’s my top pick.
However, the battery isn’t included in the overall package, and that’s the Makita’s main drawback. Having to buy a battery separately increases its overall cost, and it’s not convenient.
We would recommend the Makita to just about anyone that can fit it into their budget. It’s powerful, lightweight, easy to carry, and durable.
2. FEIN Turbo II HEPA Vacuum Cleaner Set, 8.4 Gallon, 1100W — Editor’s Choice
- Auto-Start Vacuum for power tools-allows your...
- Powerful suction with 98.4" of static water lift
This FEIN Turbo II is another option that’s great for work sites, but it’s a little more accessible to people who simply want a good vacuum for their workshop.
Its compatibility with power tools allows it to combine the benefits of an on-board dust extractor with the benefits of a general-purpose vacuum.
I recommend this vacuum to people who are generally just cleaning up dust and smaller volumes of liquid spills. That makes it great for small work sites and at-home workshops.
3. DEWALT DWH304DH Onboard Dust Extractor — Best For Tables And Rotary Hammers
- Table 1-compliant dust management solution for...
- Works on DEWALT corded and cordless 1-1/8 in. Sds...
This dust extractor is a bit different than the other options I’ve reviewed. It’s an on-board extractor. So, you can’t move it around your shop as an all-purpose cleaning tool.
For those reasons, I can only recommend this to you if you have the appropriate tools to use it. It’s too limited to work for people who just want a general-purpose tool.
DEWALT DWH304DH Short Demonstration Video
4. Vacmaster VF408 with 2-Stage Industrial Motor Wet/Dry Shop Vacuum — Best Budget Option
- 2-Stage Motor for Powerful Suction and Quiet...
- HEPA Material Exhaust Filter for Cleaner Air
The Vacmaster is designed to clean up your entire shop. It resembles a normal shop vacuum, but its 4-gallon collection container has a traditional vacuum tip to help you cover large areas quickly.
I recommend this dust collector if you’re constantly cleaning your shop. The standard model has plenty of room for dust, and it’s designed to handle big messes. It’s also fairly inexpensive. However, its five horsepower engine is a little weaker than other options. So, you’ll want to pick something else for very difficult messes.
5. Festool 583492 CT 26 E HEPA Dust Extractor — Best For Job Sites
- Automatic Tool Start & adjustable suction with...
- Supplied with 11-1/2 foot long anti-static hose...
If you work at a messy job site, this is the dust extractor for you. It’s a bit pricey, but it’s easily the most powerful vacuum on this list, and it has some really fancy features to make it worth its price.
I highly recommend this vacuum, but it’s not a practical choice for everyone. It’s pricey, and it’s overkill if you just want to keep your at-home workshop free of dust. That being said, it’s probably the best vacuum you’re going to get if you have the budget for it.
If you want a vacuum that is just as good but a little cheaper, this Festool product is a great alternative.
Festool Video Review
Dust extractors come in a lot of different variations, and each one is more suitable for some jobs than it is for others. So, I’ve created this buyer’s guide highlighting the differences between different components to help you pick the right one for your workshop or job site.
This is probably the most important thing you should look at when you go to buy a dust extractor. Some models function like your household vacuum, but some have to be mounted onto your power tools.
The portable variety is the most common, and some portable vacuums can perform the same job as the on-board variants. They’re typically what you want to go for, but on-board models aren’t obsolete.
On-board dust extractors allow you to prevent having to clean up in the first place. They attach to the motors of your favorite power tools, and they collect dust as it’s being created.
However, you can’t drag an on-board unit around to clean up messes around your workshop. So, they’re pretty limited, and they’re not a great choice as a general-purpose tool.
Suction isn’t too important for most people. Pretty much any vacuum can pick up wood dust and other light materials, but some tougher jobs will require units that are rated for 50 inches or more of static water lift strength.
First off, if you’re looking for an on-board unit, you can completely ignore this section. It’s important for portable units, though.
A few of the options I reviewed come with accessories, and many other models come with their own attachments. However, if you don’t have a way to store those attachments on the unit, you’ll find yourself walking back to whatever you use for storage every time you need a new piece.
These features aren’t necessary for models that don’t attach directly to a power tool, though. You really don’t need them if you plan on neglecting any attachment options, either.
A machine that measures water levels is also a good thing to have. If you suck up too much water, it can spill out and cause an electrical shock. A water-level detector prevents that.
Hose Length And Tips
A workshop has a lot of different crevices in it. Think of all the tight spots between your different power tools and tables. There’s a lot of them, right?
You need a hose that is long enough to get into those crevices, and it should be flexible enough to bend around parts of your tools.
However, every other option on this list can perform specific tasks better than Makita. The key to picking the right one for your needs is to establish exactly what you plan to use the vacuum for.
Thank you for reading this buyer’s guide, and I hope it helped you find the right dust vacuum for your workshop or job site.
What To Look For In a Dust Extraction System?
Here we’re going to talk a little bit about dust extraction. We want to have a look at what sort of considerations you need to take into account when you’re choosing an extractor, have a little bit of a talk about the applications and what sort of benefits a dust extractor brings when you’re working with it with tools. One, dust control is a really important consideration to a business, okay? Not only is it really important for the health of the people that are working in the business, but definitely you can reduce your cost by using dust extraction as well. When you’re looking for a dust extraction system, there are a few considerations you need to make. The other benefit of using dust extractions are the reducing consumables that you use on a job.
What Type of Dust?
At the end of the day, this is also a payback. The top bad habits of tradies out there is definitely leaving dust on-site, okay? This obviously costs money to clean up and to be able to gather that from the tour where it’s produced and put into a dust extractor. This saves you costs in cleaning up. Also, the types of dust that we’ll use out there. So cement sheet, we’re cutting all different types of cement sheet products. Silica dust has now also become quite a feature, MDF, plaster dust and this type of thing. So with that, you need to make the right decision about what type of dust that you’ll be working with. We’ll then point you towards the best dust extractor for you. The other one that you need to think about is getting on and off-site, okay?
Mobile or Stationary?
So you really need something that is mobile, that can get on-site really quickly and make it efficient. This may be that you only need a smaller dust extractor, whereas if you’re producing a lot of dust, then you’d lean towards going to something a little bit bigger. The key is that all dust has long term health effects, okay? It’s something that you really need to think about and make sure that you’re getting the right type of filtration and the right type of system that you can use with the dust extractor. So using the wrong dust extractor is one thing, that’s why we need to choose the right one, but also using a tool connected to it really needs to be designed for dust extraction. This can make a big difference in how you work healthy and also depending on how much time you need to do to clean up afterward.
So one that’s really effective in a system as well. So pretty much every application on-site has got dust applications and using the correct filter and the right capacity and having something that you can take on-site. So key considerations are what type of dust you’re going to work with. Okay? So there’s dust out there that is what we call non-hazardous dust. We move into more hazardous dust like MDF, timber, and then we look at different types of dust like plaster. So you really need to look at what type of dust that is. Even asbestos, carcinogens, so again, we can offer a particular dust extractor for that so it’s important that you get the right one. How much dust you’re going to produce is really important as well. Again, this will determine what dust extractor is best for you as far as size and taking on-site.
And is it mobile? Okay? Is it built for the site? Can I get on the site easily with it? Has it got the option to be able to stack the tool and accessories on top of the dust extractor? This makes the whole system work a lot easier. So it’s important you look for systems that are going to work correctly for you. When you get them in the car, can you lock them in one place so they don’t move around? So different things like brakes and that type of thing on it. So is it mobile enough to get on-site is the other one. And are there different bag options? So of course with all the different dust types sometimes we need to contain the dust. Other systems work where we may need to have an open bag system. This could be in relation to plaster or something like that.
So by having different bag systems you can, you can adapt it to whatever you need. Also, Bluetooth. So Bluetooth functionality. This is also a benefit where you’re working with cordless tools but still want to use that and mains power dust extractor and also for cleaning up options and this type of thing. It needs to be auto on and off, okay? So auto on and off for the tools. This means that we can work with moving back and forth from the dust extractor to turn it on. Another key consideration to make when you’re looking for a dust extractor is just how good the extraction is, okay? So with a lot of other offers on the market, you take a lot of container space up with a filter. The benefit of this is we can take a smaller unit on-site, but we can totally fill the capacity of the bag, okay?
The reason that happens is that we have got a flat filter inside the unit and the flat filter doesn’t take up any of the space inside our container. So when we look at filling up a dust bag on-site, we can totally have a solid dust bag taking all the dust away from our application. This really means that we can use it effectively, but also economically when we talk about purchasing bags with other units that you can see on the market. Sometimes it’s very unlikely that you’d fill them to 50%, okay? This is a way of using a dust extractor really effectively and making sure that you always can fill the container capacity. Less time that you need to spend changing bags and fewer bags that you go through at the end of the day. So with that, extraction really is the heart of the Dust Extraction System.
Every tool will connect up to the hose, okay? We’ve got different size hoses depending on what our application is. So sometimes where we’re extracting some cement sheet dust or something like that, we can move from a 27 mil hose to a 36 mil hose. That allows a bit more volume out of the machine as well. Different types for different dust types as I mentioned. So the most important thing you look at first is what type of dust you are working with. This will then point you towards the type of extractor you need and so that it can still be compact and functional enough for you to get on and off-site. And the system designed to work with all the tools, which is really important as well.
Last update on 2020-10-22 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
Table of Contents
- What is The Best Dust Extractor?
- 1. Makita XCV11Z — Amazon’s Choice
- 2. FEIN Turbo II HEPA Vacuum Cleaner Set, 8.4 Gallon, 1100W — Editor’s Choice
- 3. DEWALT DWH304DH Onboard Dust Extractor — Best For Tables And Rotary Hammers
- DEWALT DWH304DH Short Demonstration Video
- 4. Vacmaster VF408 with 2-Stage Industrial Motor Wet/Dry Shop Vacuum — Best Budget Option
- 5. Festool 583492 CT 26 E HEPA Dust Extractor — Best For Job Sites
- Festool Video Review
- Buyer’s Guide
- What To Look For In a Dust Extraction System?
- What Type of Dust?
- Mobile or Stationary?